44 Comments

Normally I’d never admit this on the net, but here goes because of your generous vulnerability. A couple years ago, I purchased a bra created and marketed to “folks like me” and it kinda changed my life. A part of my body that I grew up loathing suddenly became a celebration, something beautiful. I looked in the mirror for the first time, like, whoa. I’m kinda cute! The irony is that I threw out all the bras from a widely recognized chain that’s supposed to make you feel like a sexual goddess, but all that pomp and pump just made me feel fake. Now I feel real, like I’m finally cherishing the self I was born with after almost three decades of shaming her. It’s wild how easily we turn on our bodies, but it’s awesomely radical to *choose* instead to embrace these precious, intricate, scientifically near-impossible masterpieces.

Expand full comment

Masterpieces indeed!!! It only took me three decades to learn that I wasn't supposed to *fit* *into* jeans; they were supposed to *fit* *me.* HUH? If that were the entire movement of The Enlightenment, I think the world would be 500% better off! I absolutely love this tale and it fills me with a full-body smile (a smiling spleen) that there are sooo many more clothing options now that don't make us feel as though DNA/God/stardust/the universe made a mistake! OH, to be Gen Z!

Expand full comment

A smiling spleen!!! HAA!! ...Oh my heart, we are so far the opposite of mistakes. More of this, please!!

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Feb 24, 2023
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

You're so right!! I just read a book called Butts (yep) which is largely about the changing beauty standards over time, and how quickly they change!! In the 1910s, voluptuousness (for white women) was in, and in the 1920s the ideal body was totally flat! There's no possible way to keep up and yet it's so easy to feel bad that our proportions don't fit the instagram trend of the day. How absurd!

Expand full comment

I’ve been thinking about this a lot lately, and thinking about how so many of the world’s problems (and my own personal problems) spring from the fact that we forget that we are also animals, not just walking brains. I grew up with the idea of mind over body, mind dominating and conquering and torturing body in the name of discipline, and now I’m trying to transition to something closer to what Mary Oliver describes in one of my favorite poems:

“You do not have to be good.

You do not have to walk on your knees

for a hundred miles through the desert repenting.

You only have to let the soft animal of your body

Love what it loves. “

Expand full comment

I really resonated with the idea of asking why my soul chose this body.

Expand full comment

Such a profound question to ponder! (I'm certainly not the first one to ask it!)

Expand full comment

I’ve also recently been noticing some extra body on my beautiful body, and with therapy I’ve come to realize I’m trying to “keep up” with my partner (who’s a 6ft male that LOVES to run…meanwhile running is only ever something I do if I’m late to work). He can eat and drink as much and as fast he wants and seemingly doesn’t show it. And for many childhood trauma reasons, I subconsciously follow everything he does (except the running) and have learned that my body can’t take the things his can. And what’s great to realize is that I don’t want to be able to! I want to eat as slow as I please, and save the rest for later. Plus, with your beautiful insights, I’m learning my body is someone I get to thank and treat with respect, which only further helps my need to find my own perfectly imperfect regimen.

Expand full comment

I feel this, Sigrid! A few years ago I had a very brief stint with CrossFit (LOL) which was mostly a disaster BUT something I really loved about it was the emphasis on how evolution has produced bodies WITH DIFFERENT ABILITIES. The idea is that some people are made to run fast, some people are made to run far, and some people are made to carry other people ;) (of course, this is a crass reduction, but the idea can be broadly applied!) My partner too is a long-term runner and lifter who needs a lot of calories and I too will often rush to keep up (as though I'm going to "miss out" or something?)!! One thing that I found to be fun/helpful in learning about my eating habits was researching my human design (myhumandesign.com) and realizing that I have "quiet" digestion, meaning that I like to eat in silence :) Which is true!!! And weird! And fun! Why not! I love your observations and I'm so happy you're respecting your lovely being!

Expand full comment

I feel this, too! It's taken me a couple years of cooking for and with my boyfriend to finally - like, two weeks ago - realize something that seems so obvious now - that we just don't need the same amount of food. Different metabolisms! We might be more or less the same height and weight, but he's a muscly man! But something about being an only child and hyperaware of gender roles or only used to cooking and sharing food with female flatmates and friends or I don't know what just made me kind of obsessed with making our portions exactly the same - besides the fact that, well, I love food, so if he's getting a second helping I also wanna do that "just for the taste"... Seems like such a small, dumb thing, but I'm trying to listen less to my brain and more to my body on this one.

Expand full comment

I always think of my bones and my skeleton whenever I am feeling like my body isn't "good enough". I like to remind myself of the muscles underneath the skin, to the organs to the bones and then zoom into each little cell. What really prompted me to think about my body this way was a college professor who made the class learn to draw the skeleton before he brought in real life models. He said it would help us be better at drawing the actual form. He was right. I never forgot it and have used it as my own ever since!

Expand full comment

I love this!!!! You're a body genius!

Expand full comment

When I was seven months pregnant with my firstborn, my father in law basically called me fat and questioned if I was gaining a “healthy” amount of weight (I was).

This really angered me but it was also freeing in a way. It made me realize how deeply rooted the objectification of women’s bodies is. How, even when I was creating life (a miracle!) I was being judged by my body’s appearance.

All this to say, I am a goddess, my body is amazing, and I am no longer listening to anyone’s opinions but mine on this precious being that belongs to my soul in this lifetime.

Thank you, Mari for the reminders!

Expand full comment

This newsletter made me cry happy tears--the last several paragraphs in particular. You have such a gift!

Expand full comment

Oh this made me really happy!! Thank you sweet one!

Expand full comment

Oh, Mari. This is the newsletter that finally made me create a Substack account to be able to write a comment. I don't know how you do it, but the topic of your newsletters just magically reflects what's on my mind like 99% of the time! (Or is this like, a horoscope psychology thing?)

I appreciate that so much, and I'm always so excited to see what you're going to be writing about each week!

And when I saw the email subject "To be a body"... oh boy.

Maybe this is oversharing for a first comment, but here it goes: last Wednesday I went to the emergency room with horrible belly pain. After hours of testing (and fainting twice, a new experience for me), I was diagnosed with an ectopic pregnancy and major internal bleeding and got emergency surgery on the same day (also a first). I left the hospital on Saturday, but my haemoglobin levels had dropped so low that I was told it could take me up to 2 months to go back to my normal energy levels.

All of this was, obviously, pretty shocking, and I feel like there are several sides of the experience that I haven't really processed yet. It's very hard not to feel like "my body has betrayed me", especially since I don't want to have children and was on contraception (IUD), which was removed during the surgery, and now I have to start taking the pill (another first, I never wanted it) since they apparently also found evidence of endometriosis, so on top of everything else, my contraception plan and choices have been taken away from me.

Then there's the almost-dying, of course.

And then, the prospect of low energy levels for weeks. I had things to do (job interviews, a trip to Paris, volunteering to plant trees, going jogging in the almost-spring weather)! How dare you, silly body, ruin all of that?!

And at the same time.... one week ago I was still lying on a hospital bed with various tubes poking out of my body. Now I'm back home, and my biggest "problems" are getting a bit dizzy when I wash my hair or getting frustrated that I have to let others cook for me and take care of me. I'm recovering pretty fast, everyone who comes visit me expects to see me looking much worse and is surprised that I'm basically normal, and there's a lot I could be thankful for to my body. It's stronger than I expected! (I hear Adriene Mishler's voice in my head often: "I am strong".) I should probably be kinder to it, take it easy, give it what it needs. Why is it so hard to convince my brain to do that?

So your reflections really resonated today, Mari. I hope I can (re)learn alongside you. Thank you.

Expand full comment

Elena! I can't tell you how honored and chuffed I am that you would take the time to create a whole account just to leave this gorgeous response, which gave me smiles and sighs and aches and thousands of other full-body responses.

I am so, so sorry for what you went through last week. Wow, wow. You sweet brave little darling, pobrecita. I'm so glad to hear that you've been held in community even though I can so easily understand the reticence to dependence on others, phew. When I was originally misdiagnosed while becoming slowly paralyzed due to a great internal misunderstanding, a doctor told me I'd "never be independent again" which was worse than any other fate. Even being dependent for a couple weeks was a type of life I never wanted, felt like I never signed up for. It felt directly in opposition to WHO I AM.

Through all the work I've done around body acceptance/neutrality/positivity/whatever (i.e. stealing smarter people's ideas :), I've concluded that "I am a body" rather than "I have a body" and yet, in those moments of biological weakness, doesn't it feel like such a betrayal?? As though our various conditions that slow us down are akin to the WiFi not working or something?? I feel like God should have a customer service hotline in times like these. "MA'AM, I'D LIKE TO SPEAK TO THE MANAGER."

And yes it's so easy to adapt to less severe problems than ALMOST DYING but the human body is meant to very quickly adjust, which is mystifying and sometimes annoying! As soon as we begin to heal, we want to be superhuman, but gentleness is a much super trait than we get any credit for!!!

Ugh, Elena, thank you soooo much for so honestly telling your story. I'm so grateful. And so mad on your behalf. And so hoping that your brain cooperates and gives the rest of your beautiful body all the love she needs. And remembers alllll the Queen Adriene quotes!!!

Also, bless you for volunteering to plant trees. An angel among us!

Expand full comment

Mari, thank you so so much for such a thoughtful and kind reply. I know it's been like, forever, so I don't know if you'll still read this, but I've reread your comment several times in these weeks without knowing what exactly to reply to your kindness. It's meant a lot in the process of the last weeks <3 I'm doing much better physically, at least so they tell me, but it's been weird and confusing to navigate this body and I guess it will continue to be for a little while. Your comparison to the WiFi not working is SO perfect. Thank you for the perspective!!

I have to say, sometimes, when I look at the scars on my belly - the times that I manage to move on past sadness/disappointment/wondering if they're gonna be there forever, those other times, I feel a kind of tenderness for my own body that I hadn't experienced before. I am a body. I am strong. <3 I hope you're doing well, Mari.

Expand full comment

I recently started befriending my body as well. I realized it wouldn’t be much longer till it would turn to dirt so I should do my best to love and show my gratitude for all she’s done. I’ve take her so much for granted and she has been nothing but an amazing friend.

Expand full comment

I’ve been thinking about my nervous system so much, too. This was really helpful to read- thank you.

Expand full comment

I gained enough weight where I had to buy new clothes and at first I felt awful about it. Over time, through therapy, through a nutritionist, I learned that I don't have to "reverse" myself small again, I only have to work on my thinking about why I'm uncomfortable with myself in a bigger size.

Two years later I'm still working on it but it's getting better. I try to think about it as "taking up more space" in the sense that I was trying to "make myself small" for so, so, long. Now I am boldly stating to the world that I'm taking a damn bite out of it.

Love your writing here, as always! We are always rooting for Enlightened Being Mari Andrew!!!!!

Expand full comment

“To summarize Western history, then the Enlightenment happened, which was great in some ways but really threw the baby out with the bathwater when it came to care and attentiveness to the body.”

Ha! This line made me cackle. Belongs in the “Cunk on Earth” mockumentary.

On a real note, I appreciated this reflection a lot. I’m looking forward to downward dogging it tomorrow so I can picture pelvis moving around. My relationship with my body had two pivotal moments. The first came when I allowed myself to start taking long baths as an adult. It was something about sitting with my naked body in silence that made me confront what a beautiful miracle it was. The second moment came as I watched my mom’s body collapse as a result of ALS. Seeing someone senselessly stripped of their ability to walk, talk, eat, and function really forced me to examine just how magnificent my fully functioning hunk of flesh is.

Expand full comment

As usual, a glorious comment from you Maggie! I hope you moved your pelvis with aplomb and wonder!

Gosh I feel you on those baths. The tummy folds that I used to dream of chopping off as a teenager are now comforting to see spreading out in the hot water.

The experience of watching your mom's body collapse must have been a horror that defies language. I'm so so sorry you all had to go through that. Doesn't it feel like there must be a limit to human suffering?? And yet, and yet, sometimes it just keeps getting worse. Oof. Lots of love to your hunk of flesh and her brilliant mind within.

Expand full comment

Mari! I’m adding you to the list of people who has publicly acknowledged their urges to hack off folds! Do you know how validating that is?! (Also in case you’re wondering who else appears on that list so far…Lizzo…so you’re in good company)

I love that there are voices, like yours, that would’ve made my 13 year old self feel so SEEN. But it’s equally as powerful now, because so many of us walk around as adults with those parts and urges unacknowledged and tucked away. It’s the main push why I share as well.

Thank you for your words about suffering. I know that you have experienced things that defy words as well. It truly was an experience where I woke up somedays demanding to understand why someone was left to suffer so much. I’m not sure I’ll ever have the answer for my mom or I, but I’ve certainly found little gifts, (sometimes microscopic but still there) along the way.

Okay, I’m done now. Love & light. ❤️

Expand full comment

I related so much to this essay! I’ve been on weight-gaining medication for sudden and severe neuropathic pain for the last two years. I’m now slowly coming off it as I learn other ways to manage my pain and I think I’m finding losing the weight harder than gaining it. When I was gaining weight I knew it was a side-effect of the medication that was allowing me to get up in the morning. I never judged myself, and I did think of my body as a friend I needed to support in return for the pain she was bearing for me. Now that I’m returning to a more familiar body, it’s easy to forget that she’s been through a lot and still deserves kind and gentle treatment. I’m also living in a new country where my friends and colleagues don’t know my body’s history - but I still do. This was a good reminder to continue to be a caring and accepting friend to her!

Expand full comment

I get you!!! (Also, I'm so, so sorry about the neuropathic pain. I've had it too and it's unreal!) I was so sweet to myself during illness recovery and then adjusted back to being critical so quickly. Annoying how that happened! I love what you said about your friends not knowing your body's history but YOU do. Yes, yes, I need to remember this too.

Expand full comment

When I was in the worst of the pain, I read My Inner Sky and it helped me so much. So thank you very much 💛

Expand full comment

Ahhh that means the world to me! 😭

Expand full comment

I so relate to this essay and your comment! I had an extremely rough (and traumatic) birth that also landed me on some weight-gaining meds. I adore your way of thinking about it like a kindness for bearing the pain. And yet I’m also still really struggling to feel at home in this new body, not because it’s bad in some way, but because of how utterly unfamiliar it has become after growing and birthing a child. And I clearly had some arbitrary timeline on mind for when I “should” be healed (and let me tell you 15 months and counting was not it...) which makes that kindness quite hard to extend some days. But I’m more in my body now than ever before in my life so it’s something I am really working on!

Expand full comment

The unfamiliarity aspect is awful. I still look in the mirror sometimes and get a shock cause it my head my body still looks like it did pre-pain, like it had for such a long time that it was still the me I recognised. I have a hard time looking at recent photos too (who is she?) but it’s something I’m working on. And reminding myself that my body is of value for the things I get to DO with it, not just as an object. I get it and I really feel for you!

Expand full comment

I have Dissociative Fugue so I probably appear as though I am transcending my body when I have actually just popped out of my skin for a little while. I used to be a big Meditator until I realised that between the Meditating me and the Dissociating me I was spending very little time ‘at home’ so to speak. I realised how deeply ungrounded I was, despite any amount of Chakra work and no matter how often I visualised myself connected to our lovely Mother Earth with a big tendrilly anchored root system. I am currently working on being more present, more ‘in the now’, no longer grieving my past or fearing the future but getting to know who I am and what I need or want even. Your Newsletters speak to me. Thank you 🙏🏻

Expand full comment

I have always called my body it and never ‘her’. And since I had been fat-shamed as a kid, I have grown up to loathe myself and my body as soon as I start to gain weight (which is my current situation).

Since I don’t live in the US, I can’t come to your retreat (I wish I could), do you have any recommendations (books/ podcasts/ programs) that might help me become friendlier towards my body.

Also, thank you for this post. I needed this! ❤️

Expand full comment

I have to tell you that I’m sure it’s not some mystical thing but I found your article about the Best Breakup Advice a while back and thought it was so different that I’d better hang onto it for when I need it. I have since shared it with so many people who have gratefully thanked me and whom I guess found it helpful during a heartache. It’s like my break up Bible. You are always credited of course as I share it like it is seen on the actual page.

Well yesterday someone was going through a breakup and I sent it and it didn’t work. Today it did (phew) and I realized I’ve never read anything else you’ve written. Now this winter I went from being the girl everyone gushed over being very thin while eating any amount of food my whole 48 years to suddenly becoming well, overweight. I realized I’d been a big girl in a skinny girls body all along and so much has changed. I never felt flesh like this and no clothes fit, even larger ones I think will be baggy are not! I want to not let it bother me but this body is a whole new ball game in every way. I go one way and it goes another! Did you know if you don’t dry both thighs off at once they will never get dry as they are star crossed lovers who can’t be separated? I did not. I am really struggling to accept this and I was fully prepared to embrace all of life’s changes. That’s what I thought. I was thinking just how badly I want to go online and scream in all caps ISNT ANYONE ELSE AS ANGRY ABOUT THIS AGING BUSINESS AS I AM? Why is no one talking about how life changing this is?!?

And that’s when I decided for no specific reason to check out your blog and this is what came up first. Cosmic perhaps?

Im going to say thanks for your wisdom and lucky for me I crossed your path. Oh and I have no expectations about your other work. No one can be this good every time. Right? I guess I’ll find out.

Expand full comment